Published in 2016 by Margaret K. McElderry Books | 3.8 feathers
*This review contains spoilers*
This is a short story collection set after the events of City of Heavenly Fire, in which Simon goes to the Shadowhunter Academy to become a Shadowhunter and regain his memories.
If you’re wondering about the weird rating, it’s because I rated each short story individually and the overall rating is an average of each individual rating.
Overall, I thought this collection was a bit all over the place. There were some stories that I either loved (the one about James Herondale <3) or liked a lot, but sometimes it felt as if the authors were trying a bit too hard. In some of the stories, the characters seemed slightly ridiculed. It was so obvious that they were supposed to be funny, but instead it came across as forced and fell flat. You could also tell how Izzy was testing them in The Evil We Love, again due to the characterization – Izzy just felt so off that it became obvious that something wasn’t entirely right.
There’s also the story set in the London Institute, where Jessie ends up saving them from the demon, where I found it a bit weird that a demon actually got into the Institute. And how the h**l do you hide people, however small, in chimneys?
Then there were instances where I fell in love with the characters, especially in Nothing but Shadows about James Herondale. I could relate to him so much, and it spoke to my literature-student heart how his ability to become a shadow was so symbolic of him feeling lonely. It was definitely my favourite story in the entire collection <3.
At times it was also pretty obvious that these stories were published individually before they were published as a bind-up, because they would occasionally be a bit over-explanatory and mention/explain something that just happened in the previous story. This seemed slightly unnecessary – I see why it was done, as it would have been easy to forget plot points if it had been a while since you read the last story, but perhaps those passages could have been edited to make this run more smoothly as a collection.
To wrap this all up, I thought I’d show you my individual ratings:
Welcome to Shadowhunter Academy (Cassandra Clare & Sarah Rees Brennan) – 3 feathers
The Lost Herondale (Cassandra Clare and Robin Wasserman) – 4 feathers
The Whitechapel Fiend (Cassandra Clare & Maureen Johnson) – 3.5 feathers
Nothing but Shadows (Cassandra Clare & Sarah Rees Brennan) – 5 feathers
The Evil We Love (Cassandra Clare and Robin Wasserman) – 3 feathers
Pale Kings and Princes (Cassandra Clare and Robin Wasserman) – 4 feathers
Bitter of Tongue (Cassandra Clare and Sarah Rees Brennan) – 4 feathers
The Fiery Trial (Cassandra Clare and Maureen Johnson) – 4 stars
Born to Endless Night (Cassandra Clare and Sarah Rees Brennan) – 3.5 feathers
Angels Twice Descending (Cassandra Clare and Robin Wasserman) – 4 feathers